Powerful Special Interests Should Not Trump Children's Health Needs
December 23, 2009 |10:36 | Others By : Team X
A theologian friend shared the story of taking her car to a Jiffy Lube for servicing. Not having anything to read, she picked up a manual on the coffee table about boating. A chapter on the rules for what happens when boats encounter one another on the open sea described two kinds of craft: burdened and privileged. The craft with power that can accelerate and push its way through the waves, change direction, and stop on demand is the burdened one. The craft dependent on the forces of nature, wind, tide, and human effort to keep going is the privileged craft. Since powerful boats can make their way forward under their own power, they are burdened with responsibility to give the right of way to the powerless or privileged vessels dependent on the vagaries of the tide, wind, and weather. "Who wrote this thing?" she asked. "Billy Graham? Mother Teresa? What's going on in our land when the New Jersey State Department of Transportation knows that the powerful must give way if the powerless are to make safe harbor and the government of the United States and the Church of Jesus Christ and other people of God are having trouble with the concept?"
In the current debate on national health reform that's exactly what is happening. The very fragile boat of children has been submerged and buffeted in our political process, huge waves and the wake of the burdened boats -- powerful insurance and drug companies and lobbyists for other wealthy organized constituencies who make big campaign contributions and can mount a strong constituent voice of voters. The controversy-seeking media has ignored the huge looming injustice from the proposed abolition of the successful and cost effective Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP), enacted in 1997 with the bipartisan leadership of Senators Ted Kennedy and Orrin Hatch, in the House bill and its weakening in the Senate Finance Committee bill. That millions of children will be worse off if CHIP is abolished or weakened has been drowned out by the strident Tea Party, anti-immigrant and abortion foes.


















